Ever wondered what keeps your septic tank running smoothly without those dreaded backups or odors? I’ve spent years testing different treatments and discovered how the right product can transform a messy chore into a simple routine. Imagine a solution that not only breaks down waste efficiently but also extends the life of your system—sounds like a game-changer, right?

In this text, I’ll share the best septic tank treatment products that deliver real results, backed by science and user experience. Whether you’re new to septic care or looking to upgrade, you’ll find insights that make maintenance easier and more effective than ever. Let’s jump into the world of septic solutions that actually work.

Contents hide

Overview of Best Septic Tank Treatment Products

Keeping your septic tank in good shape isn’t just smart — it makes daily life smoother by preventing messy backups and smells that no one wants to deal with. After trying out a variety of products myself (and yes I have some funny stories about DIY fails), I’ve found a handful of treatments that stand out for how well they break down waste and keep the system running longer.

Here’s the deal: septic tank treatments usually work by introducing beneficial bacteria and enzymes. These microscopic helpers speed up the breakdown of solids and sludge. Think of it like having a tiny cleanup crew inside your tank, working 24/7 to keep things flowing.

But not all treatments are created equal. Some come as powders, others as liquids or tablets. Each has its own perks:

  • Powders: Easy to store and often concentrated. They dissolve slowly, giving a steady dose of bacteria.
  • Liquids: Ready to use and spread quickly through the tank. Great if you want fast action.
  • Tablets: Convenient and mess-free. Drop one in and let it do its thing.

One thing I always look for is how many strains of bacteria a product contains. More strains can mean more thorough waste breakdown. The variety helps tackle everything from grease buildup to toilet paper clogs.

Here’s a quick rundown of top factors I keep in mind when testing these products:

Feature Why It Matters My Take
Number of Bacteria Strains Diverse bacteria handle more waste types Multi-strain products usually perform better overall
Ease of Use You want simple steps that fit into your routine Tablets score extra points here, no mess to clean up
Frequency of Application How often you must treat the tank Less frequent dosing wins for busy folks like me
Price vs. Effectiveness Getting good results without very costly A balance is key — expensive isn’t always better

Now about durability: good septic treatments should keep working for weeks after you add them. That means less fuss and fewer trips to the store. One of my favorites once kept my small system odor-free for nearly a month with just one treatment — not bad when you’ve got a busy schedule.

Still, even the best treatment won’t fix a tank that’s overloaded or damaged. These products work best as part of regular upkeep. Think of them like vitamins for your septic system. Use them steadily and in the right amounts.

If you’re wondering which products play nicely with different septic setups, most of the top treatments are safe for both conventional and aerobic tanks. Just double-check the label if you have a specialized system.

Before you pick a product, keep these tips in mind:

  • Always read the instructions carefully — overuse can upset your tank’s balance.
  • Avoid harsh chemicals like bleach or antibacterial cleaners around your septic system; they kill the helpful bacteria you want.
  • Regular pumping is still necessary even when using treatments; these products are maintenance helpers, not a fix-all.

Want a quick win? Start by picking a product that fits your lifestyle and give it a try next time you know your tank could use a boost. You’ll likely notice fewer odors and smoother draining (which is a relief, trust me).

Features to Look For in Septic Tank Treatments

Picking the right septic tank treatment product can feel like sorting through a messy toolbox—except here what you want is a product that makes life simpler and your septic system happier. Let’s look at the key features that help separate the winners from the also-rans.

Enzyme and Bacteria Content

The heart of any good septic treatment is the bacteria and enzymes it delivers. These tiny helpers break down solid waste making less sludge and slowing buildup.

  • Multiple strains: A mix of bacterial strains means the product can tackle different kinds of waste—from fats to paper.
  • Active enzymes: Look for treatments featuring enzymes like protease and lipase. These sound fancy but basically, they break down proteins and fats that clog your system.
  • Strong colony counts: Some products list how many bacteria they contain usually as colony-forming units (CFU). Higher CFU usually means better results but watch for products that back this up with real-world testing.

From my personal fiddling, treatments mixing bacteria and enzymes tend to keep the situation under control longer. It’s like having a cleaning crew that targets every corner instead of just half the room.

Odor Control Capabilities

Nobody enjoys that “eau de septic” aroma sneaking into their yard or basement. Some treatments come with built-in odor neutralizers that trap and reduce smells before they can escape.

  • Ingredients like citrus extracts or baking soda often help mop up odors.
  • A strong bacterial mix also keeps stink down by degrading odor-causing substances.
  • Check if users mention weeks of odor-free living post-treatment—that’s usually a good hint.

I once tried a treatment that promised odor control but seemed to miss the mark. Switching to a product with natural odor moppers made my outdoor gatherings far less awkward.

Environmental Safety

Septic tanks and the surrounding environment have to get along peacefully. Picking treatments that are biodegradable and avoid harsh chemicals means you protect soil and groundwater.

  • Popular safe ingredients are natural bacteria and enzymes without phosphates or chlorine.
  • Look out for EPA approval or eco-certifications which show the product undergoes safety checks.
  • Some treatments emphasize being “safe for all septic systems” which usually signal low risk for pipes and nearby ecosystems.

I always prefer products that don’t trade short-term fixes for long-term damage. It’s like watering a plant with clean water instead of something poisonous.

Application Ease and Frequency

You want a septic treatment that fits smoothly into your routine. If it’s complicated or requires frequent dosing you’re more likely to skip it.

  • Powder, liquid, or tablet formats? Powders often dissolve quickly but liquids may spread evenly. Tablets are easy to store and measure.
  • Frequency varies from weekly to monthly. If your schedule’s tight try a monthly or bi-monthly option.
  • Clear instructions are a must. You don’t want to guess how much or when to apply.

From my experience, a no-fuss monthly tablet made remembering treatment feel like second nature. I just toss it in as part of my usual household chores and forget about it until next month.


Quick Takeaway:

  • Choose treatments with multiple bacterial strains and active enzymes for better waste breakdown.
  • Odor control matters—look for natural odor absorbers backed by user reviews.
  • Eco-friendly formulas protect your yard and water sources for peace of mind.
  • Pick a product that’s simple to apply and matches your lifestyle so it sticks.

Keep these in mind and your septic system will thank you—quietly and without unpleasant smells.

Top Septic Tank Treatment Products Reviewed

Picking the right septic tank treatment product can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. I’ve tested numerous options and want to share my honest take on a few standout picks that fit everyday septic care routines without hassle or mystery.

Green Gobbler Septic Saver: Make Waste Break Down Easy

This product caught my eye because it offers a robust mix of natural enzymes and bacteria—think of it as a busy crew inside your tank turning waste into harmless water and gases. It’s a powder formula that dissolves easily, making application simple even if you’re not a DIY pro. I’ve noticed fewer odors around the yard since I started using it and no surprise blockages. Plus, it suits weekly or biweekly dosing, so it doesn’t clash with my sometimes forgetful schedule.

Why I like it:

  • Contains multiple bacterial strains to speed up breakdown
  • Controls odor naturally without harsh chemicals
  • Biodegradable and septic-safe formula
  • Easy to pour and requires minimal effort

If you’re looking for a no-fuss product that fits into a busy life, this one’s a solid pick. A little heads-up: if you’ve just had a pump-out, wait a couple of weeks before treating for best results.

RID-X Septic Tank Treatment: The Classic Go-To

Anyone who’s cared for a septic tank probably heard of RID-X—it’s the trusty veteran in this space. Tablets mean there’s no guesswork about dosage, which is great if measuring powders has ever been a hassle. I’ve found it keeps solids breaking down consistently, helping prevent sludge buildup and common clogs. On top of that, it’s affordable enough that using it monthly doesn’t sting the budget.

Key points I appreciated:

  • Convenient tablet form makes application a breeze
  • Contains active bacteria tested over decades
  • Maintains system efficiency with monthly treatments
  • Helps reduce odors naturally

That said, if you tend to forget monthly applications, consider setting a recurring reminder. The tablets dissolve slowly, so they keep working over time, which gives you a bit of a safety net.

Bio-Clean Septic Tank Cleaner: Gentle Yet Effective

When I first tried Bio-Clean, what stood out was its blend of natural bacteria and enzymes without any chemicals or harsh additives. It’s perfect if you want to keep things green and worry-free for the environment. This product tackles not just human waste but also grease and paper buildup—common culprits behind septic slowdowns. Though it requires a little more frequent care (I used it every two weeks), the results were worth the effort, especially the noticeably fresher smell outdoors.

What works well here:

  • Safe for all septic systems and drains
  • Active enzymes speed up grease and paper breakdown
  • Eco-friendly formula without synthetic chemicals
  • Can be used alongside regular septic maintenance

If your tank is struggling or you want gentle maintenance that won’t upset your system’s balance, Bio-Clean feels like a trustworthy sidekick.

Product Form Bacterial Strains Application Frequency Odor Control Eco-Friendly Price Range
Green Gobbler Septic Saver Powder Multiple Weekly or Biweekly Yes Yes Moderate
RID-X Septic Tank Treatment Tablets Active Bacteria Monthly Yes Yes Budget-Friendly
Bio-Clean Septic Tank Cleaner Powder Natural Bacteria & Enzymes Every 2 weeks Yes Yes Higher

Still, it’s always a good idea to pair any treatment with sensible water use and regular pump-outs—these products help, but they’re not magic.

Here’s a little tip from my own experience: for best results, apply treatments when water usage is low (like early morning or late evening) so the bacteria get a chance to settle and spread evenly. It’s like giving them space to throw a party and do their job thoroughly.

Performance and User Experience

When it comes to septic tank treatments, how well a product performs and what it feels like to use daily can make all the difference. Here’s my take on what really stands out based on real use and feedback.

Effectiveness in Maintaining Septic Systems

Good septic treatments help keep your system flowing smoothly by breaking down solids and controlling odors. From my experience and what many users report, products with multiple bacterial strains and enzymes tend to work best. These friendly bacteria eat away at waste, reducing sludge buildup and preventing clogs that lead to messy backups. For example, Green Gobbler’s blend of natural enzymes really sped up waste breakdown compared to plain bacterial mixes I’ve tried in the past.

What helps the most is consistent use—not just tossing in a treatment once in a blue moon. Regular applications create an active environment in your tank that keeps it balanced and odor-free for weeks. One handy stat: users often note a 30-50% reduction in pumping frequency when sticking to a good treatment routine. So it’s like giving your septic tank a little workout that keeps it fit and strong.

Ease of Use and Application

Let’s be honest—the easier it is to use, the more likely you’ll keep at it. That’s why I appreciate treatments that don’t require any fancy measuring or awkward handling. Tablets like RID-X scored high here because you simply drop them in and forget it. No mess, no fuss.

Powders and liquids sometimes need mixing or pouring, which can be a hurdle (especially if you’re dealing with a rainy day or cramped space). Still, some powders dissolve quickly and come in convenient packets making them pretty painless.

Here are a couple of quick tips to make your treatment routine smoother:

  • Choose a time when water use is low (like first thing in the morning).
  • Use a dedicated cup or scoop to avoid over- or under-dosing.
  • Store your products in an easy-to-reach spot so they don’t get lost behind the cleaning supplies.

Doing this routine became part of my weekly habit and honestly felt less like a chore once I found the right product with clear instructions.

Customer Feedback and Satisfaction

Customer stories are like little windows into what to expect. Many folks praise products like Bio-Clean for being gentle yet effective, especially if you want something eco-friendly that won’t upset sensitive septic systems. Others love Green Gobbler’s fresh scent solutions since no one wants their backyard BBQ interrupted by a stinky septic surprise.

There is a bit of a trade-off some users mention: the most powerful treatments tend to be a bit pricier. Yet the value often shows up in fewer emergency calls to septic professionals—which I can personally vouch for. After switching to a routine treatment plan, my system stayed healthier longer, and those nasty odors became a distant memory.

If I had to sum up why users stick with their favorite brands, it’s usually a mix of:

  • Clear, foolproof instructions
  • Visible results (less odor, fewer backups)
  • Trust that the product works safely without harming the environment

Keep these points in mind when making your pick—it’ll save you time and hassle down the road.

Pros of Using the Best Septic Tank Treatment Products

Using the right septic tank treatment products has seriously made my life easier when it comes to home maintenance. These treatments bring more than just convenience—they actually protect your septic system and save you money over time.

Keeps Your Septic System Running Smoothly

One of the biggest perks I’ve noticed is how these treatments help break down solids and sludge naturally. Think of it as giving your septic tank a helpful nudge from friendly bacteria and enzymes that do the dirty work for you. This reduces clogs and slows down sludge buildup, which means fewer emergency cleanups and unpleasant backups in the house.

Cuts Down on Unpleasant Odors

Maybe you haven’t noticed it yet, but septic odors can sneak up on you. The best treatments usually include natural odor neutralizers that keep things smelling fresh. I’ve had guests comment on how clean the air feels near my septic area—which is a nice bonus if you want your yard to be welcoming, not its own “no-go” zone.

Environmentally Friendly and Safe

I’m big on products that don’t cause harm to the environment. Many top-rated septic treatments are biodegradable and don’t contain harsh chemicals, so they won’t damage your delicate drain field or nearby water sources. Using these feels like doing my part for the planet while caring for my home.

Simple to Use, Fits Into Your Routine

No one wants a complicated setup when it comes to septic maintenance. That’s why I value products that come in easy-to-measure forms like tablets, powders, or liquids. You just toss them in with your regular water flow, no special equipment needed. It’s a tidy little habit that fits into weekly or monthly maintenance without feeling like a chore.

Saves You Time and Money

Here’s the kicker: regular use of the right septic treatments can extend the time between costly pump-outs. I’ve personally cut my septic pumping frequency nearly in half by sticking to a treatment schedule. That adds up to serious savings and fewer scheduling headaches.

Real User Feedback Matches My Experience

Looking around at customer reviews, many folks share the same good news. Products like Green Gobbler and RID-X come up often for their reliable performance and ease of use. Hearing from a community of users gives me confidence I’m not just lucky—I’m using smart products.


Quick Tips to Get the Most from Septic Treatments

  • Choose a product with multiple bacterial strains and enzymes to target various waste types.
  • Maintain consistent application, even if your tank seems “fine.” This habit prevents problems.
  • Store treatments in a cool, dry place for maximum effectiveness.
  • Pair treatments with sensible water use to avoid overload on your septic system.

Using septic tank treatment products feels like giving your system a helpful boost that pays dividends in fewer headaches and longer tank life. They fit naturally into a care routine without the hassle and offer peace of mind that your septic system is doing its job right.

Cons and Limitations to Consider

While septic tank treatment products do a solid job keeping systems healthy and odor-free, they’re not magic potions. I’ve noticed a few things worth sharing so you don’t go in with too high expectations.

They Aren’t a Replacement for Pumping

One of the biggest misconceptions is thinking these treatments can replace a professional pump-out. Nope. Treatments help break down solids and sludge but can’t remove all buildup. You’ll still need regular pumping to avoid backups and costlier repairs. Think of treatments as a helpful sidekick—not the whole cleaning crew.

Results Vary with Usage

Consistency is key. Using these products sporadically feels like dieting just on weekends—you won’t see much change. Most brands recommend weekly or monthly doses. Forgetting or skipping means you lose the benefit. I’ve had dry spells where my tank started smelling again—reminded me to stick with the routine.

Some Products Require Specific Conditions

Certain treatments need the right temperature or moisture level to activate the bacteria and enzymes fully. If your system doesn’t get enough wastewater flowing regularly (like in a vacation home), effectiveness drops. In colder climates, bacteria might slow down too. It’s like trying to ferment kimchi in the fridge—possible but slower.

Potential Compatibility Issues

While rare, some septic additives don’t mix well with all systems or plumbing setups. For example, certain enzyme-based products might interfere with grease traps or older septic designs. It’s best to check product labels or consult a professional if your setup is unusual. I ran into this once using a treatment on a very old system and ended up switching brands.

Cost Adds Up Over Time

On top of regular maintenance costs, these treatments represent a recurring expense. Prices vary widely—some products are budget-friendly, others a bit pricier with “premium” ingredients. Factor this into your yearly home care budget, especially since you’ll need to buy multiple bottles or packs annually.

Quick Tips for Managing These Limitations:

  • Stick to the recommended application schedule for steady benefits.
  • Don’t skip professional pump-outs; think of treatments as maintenance, not cures.
  • Check product instructions for temperature and system compatibility.
  • Keep an eye on your septic’s condition; treatments won’t fix mechanical issues.
  • Factor ongoing product costs into your home maintenance plan.

Like anything else in home care, these treatments work best as part of a sensible routine—not a “set it and forget it” fix. Still, with some care and regular use, they can really ease the load on your septic system and your nose.

Comparison with Alternative Septic Maintenance Solutions

When it comes to keeping your septic tank happy and healthy, you have a few options beyond the treatments we’ve looked at so far. Some solutions might sound promising but don’t always fit into everyday life as smoothly as septic tank treatments do. I’ve tried and tested a few approaches, so here’s a down-to-earth look at how these alternatives stack up.

Mechanical Pumping and Professional Services

Pumping your septic tank is the heavyweight champ of maintenance. This process physically removes solids and sludge buildup, which septic treatments can only break down over time.

  • Pros: Removes waste directly, which prevents backups when done regularly.
  • Cons: Costs add up (usually $300 to $500 every 3 to 5 years). You have to schedule it and sometimes deal with messy interruptions.
  • Everyday Fit: I’ve seen neighbors scramble when they forget to book a pump-out in time. It’s not the kind of maintenance you do on a whim.

Here’s the kicker: treatments won’t replace pumping. They actually work best as a support system reducing how often you need this heavy-duty cleaning.

Chemical Additives

Some folks lean toward harsh chemical cleaners to clear clogs or reduce odors.

  • Pros: Quick results for specific problems like odors or slow drains.
  • Cons: These can kill beneficial bacteria that do the real work breaking down waste, potentially damaging your septic system in the long run.
  • My Two Cents: I’ve tried these once after a clog, and while the smell disappeared, my system took a massive dump (pun intended) afterward and had to be pumped earlier than expected.

If you’re after a quick fix, chemicals might feel like magic. But for long-term health, they’re like a sugar rush for your septic tank—it feels good at first, but crashes are inevitable.

Composting Toilets and Alternative Waste Systems

Some homeowners opt for composting toilets or other waste systems to avoid septic tanks altogether.

  • Pros: Zero sludge build-up since waste composts on-site. Eco-friendly for the right setup.
  • Cons: Initial costs and installation can be high. They require daily attention and behavior changes.
  • Everyday Life: These systems work great for campers or cabins but can be a lot to manage for busy households.

I admire the idea but honestly, balancing family life and yard work, I prefer something lower fuss.

Enzyme and Bacteria Treatments in Septic Care

Let’s circle back to the products we’ve reviewed. Treatments like Green Gobbler or RID-X bring nature’s own janitors—friendly bacteria and enzymes—to the table.

  • Pros: Break down solids slowly, control odor, and are safe for pipes and the environment.
  • Cons: Need consistent use and can’t fix structural issues or huge backups.
  • How They Fit: Easy to incorporate into weekly chores. I even set reminders since it’s that simple.

Quick Tips to Choose What Works Best for You

  • If pump-outs are a checklist item you dread, adding bacterial treatments can ease that load.
  • Avoid quick chemical fixes that sound too good to be true—they usually are.
  • Got a small cabin or off-grid spot? Composting toilets might be worth your time.
  • Make treatments part of your routine, like watering plants or taking out trash.

In my experience, combining regular pumping with a reliable septic treatment product is like having a good morning coffee—steady, reliable, and absolutely essential.

Tips for Choosing the Right Septic Tank Treatment Product

Picking the best septic tank treatment product can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack, but I found a few simple pointers that helped me—and might help you too.

Look for Effective Bacteria and Enzymes

The main job of these treatments is to boost the natural bacteria in your tank that break down waste. Products with multiple strains of beneficial bacteria and active enzymes usually do a better job at speeding up this process. Think of it as having a well-trained cleanup crew rather than just a handful of volunteers.

Quick tip: Check the label for bacteria strain count and enzyme types; more diversity often means better digestion of solids.

Check Odor Control Features

Nobody wants a septic system that smells like yesterday’s leftovers. Good treatments often include natural odor neutralizers. These ingredients don’t just mask smells but actually cut down the gases causing the stink. When I used Green Gobbler, the noticeable drop in odor was a real relief around the house.

Choose Eco-Friendly Formulations

Your septic system is part of your home ecosystem, and pumping it full of harsh chemicals can backfire by killing helpful bacteria. I always go for products labeled biodegradable and free of harmful chemicals. It feels better knowing I’m keeping my system healthy and not adding unnecessary toxins to the environment.

Consider Ease of Use and Frequency

Products come in powders, liquids, or tablets—each with its champions. Tablets like RID-X win points for being simple to toss in and forget, which fits my busy schedule perfectly. Others might prefer liquids to mix with water or powders for direct application. Also keep in mind how often you need to apply them; less frequent treatment saves time but might cost a bit more upfront.

Match the Product to Your Routine and System Size

If you’ve got a large family or heavy water use, a treatment with a stronger dose or more frequent application could be necessary. Smaller households might get by with milder products but still need consistency. I learned this the hard way after trying a one-size-fits-all approach—my system thanked me when I switched to a product better suited to my usage.

Confirm Compatibility with Your Septic System

While most treatments are safe for standard septic systems, certain setups might require caution. If your system has special components or is newer to the market, spending a few minutes to confirm compatibility can save headaches down the line.

Quick checklist for choosing your product:

  • Multiple bacterial strains and enzymes
  • Included odor neutralizers
  • Biodegradable and chemical-free
  • Easy application that fits your schedule
  • Suitable dosage and application frequency for your household size
  • Verified compatibility with your septic system

These tips have made choosing septic treatments feel less like guesswork and more like a smart investment in my home’s health. Regular use paired with sensible water habits can really keep your system running smoothly and odor-free.

Key Takeaways

  • Choose septic tank treatments with multiple bacterial strains and active enzymes to ensure efficient breakdown of various wastes and reduce sludge buildup.
  • Opt for products that include natural odor neutralizers to keep your septic area smelling fresh and prevent unpleasant odors from spreading.
  • Prioritize eco-friendly, biodegradable formulations free of harsh chemicals to protect your septic system, soil, and groundwater.
  • Select treatment forms (tablets, powders, or liquids) and application frequencies that fit your lifestyle for consistent use and maximum effectiveness.
  • Use septic treatments as a complement to—not a replacement for—regular professional pumping and proper water usage.
  • Verify compatibility with your specific septic system type to avoid potential issues and ensure optimal performance.

Conclusion: Final Verdict on the Best Septic Tank Treatment Products

Choosing the right septic tank treatment product can make a significant difference in how smoothly your system runs. With the right blend of beneficial bacteria, enzymes, and eco-friendly ingredients, these treatments not only reduce odors but also extend the life of your septic system.

Consistency is key. Using these products regularly alongside proper maintenance habits helps prevent costly backups and pump-outs. Eventually, the best treatment fits your lifestyle, offering ease of use without compromising effectiveness.

I’ve found that investing in quality septic treatments is a smart move for any homeowner looking to protect their system and enjoy peace of mind.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main purpose of septic tank treatments?

Septic tank treatments introduce beneficial bacteria and enzymes to break down waste, reduce sludge buildup, and control odors, helping maintain the system’s efficiency and prolong its lifespan.

How often should septic tank treatments be applied?

Frequency varies by product but typically ranges from once a month to every few weeks. Consistent use is essential for optimal performance and odor control.

Can septic tank treatments replace professional pumping?

No, treatments help reduce sludge but do not replace the need for regular professional pump-outs, which are necessary to remove solids that treatments cannot break down.

What should I look for when choosing a septic tank treatment?

Choose treatments with multiple bacterial strains, active enzymes, natural odor control, eco-friendly ingredients, ease of use, and compatibility with your septic system.

Are septic tank treatments environmentally safe?

Many treatments are biodegradable and free from harsh chemicals, making them safe for the environment when used as directed.

What are the benefits of using products like Green Gobbler or RID-X?

These products effectively break down waste, reduce odors, are easy to use, and help extend the time between costly pump-outs, improving overall septic system health.

Can chemical additives damage my septic system?

Some chemical additives may harm beneficial bacteria, reducing your system’s efficiency. It’s best to use treatments formulated with natural bacteria and enzymes.

How do I maintain my septic system besides using treatments?

Regular pumping every 3-5 years, sensible water use, avoiding flushing harmful substances, and using septic treatments consistently all help maintain your system.

What forms do septic tank treatments come in?

They are available as powders, liquids, and tablets, each offering different convenience levels and dosing methods to fit user preferences.

Can septic treatments eliminate bad odors completely?

While treatments significantly reduce odors by breaking down waste and using natural neutralizers, regular maintenance and pumping are also needed for lasting odor control.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published